I could get into the ethics and philosophy of the various factions of hunting fans—and I would have a good time doing that, too—and from my general and blather by-product-specific perspectives, I can understand virtually any hunting style—with the notable exception of trophy-hunting—but again, that's not exactly related to my point.
A "sportsman" will be the first to tell you that hunting is about more than meat. There is a spirituality to it, though it varies on just as many levels as any other spirituality, from the deep and devotional followers who live in constant anticipation of their next, profoundly sacred pilgrimage, to the casual, weekend-worshipper whose interest is evenly divided between getting out of routine household chores and the somewhat-droning sermon at hand.
Thus, the True Sportsmen tend to disdain—to some degree—the Meat Hunters. Even if the meat hunter might tremble with the same fervor that the true sportsmen experiences from time to time, they are not the same, for the meat hunters will not make an effort if to for the fact that they intend to eat what they kill ... they are less likely to seek new sites, pursue new game, or pass up on a Sure Thing for the chance at a Maybe Bigger.
As a (lapsed) meat hunter who lives with a true sportsman, I am very well aware of the distinct differences in our philosophies. I no longer choose to partake of the (often dubious) "thrill" of the hunt when faced with inclement weather, or an increased density of hunters in the field, or even an increased fee for a license. I do not have so great a need to hunt that I see a fair exchange in my comfort—and hours of sleep—for a chance to stalk wild game in the great outdoors, as opposed to Little Girl's daddy, who will happily make do on three hours of sleep during turkey season, for example. As for me, well, I no longer concede that wild turkey tastes THAT much better than an on-sale Butterball®.
Of course, neither does Little Girl's daddy, for the opportunity to put meat on the table was never his primary motivator in hunting. While we both enjoy the rawness of nature and the challenge of providing food in the very basic sense of such a venture, to me, it's more of a necessary evil than a way of life. I do not enjoy practicing the necessary techniques and calls, and I certainly do not savor the expense of time and energy involved.
No, when I hunted—mainly pheasant and pronghorn antelope, and all of it in Wyoming—I hunted for food: for the ability to take my necessary ingestion of calories all the way from the field to the dinner table, getting my own hands dirty and, in so doing, acquiring complete and total understanding of what it took to put a steak on my plate. There was no hiding behind a plastic tray, neatly wrapped in cellophane and presented with the clean, gloved hands of a grocery-store butcher ... not at all. There was sweat, there were tears, and there was blood—the sight of it, the scent of it, and the slowly-cooling warmth of it.
As it should be for everyone who chooses to eat meat, I think, but I was not going to go there, was I? :)
Musically, I make a more enthusiastic meat hunter than I did with respect to wild game—I don't mind investing my time at Amazon, listening to samples and comparing notes. I don't mind the discomfort (and the chair that sits before the computer can only dream of rivaling the lousier goose blinds I've had the distinct displeasure of crouching in, I'll have you know), or the effort of tracking down a snippet I've heard on the Internet or radio (ask me about the time I got enthralled with a defunct band called Shun). I do what I have to in order to procure music that moves me, and I do it with the single-minded focus of the dedicated religious zealot.
However, while I can wax poetic and go off and on and on and on about my favorite styles or qualities or songs, I cannot discuss it with knowledge so much as I can with instinct, and I cannot analyze it with surety born of intellect so much as heart.
In other words, dear musical sportsmen, I can savor the steak or the hamburger just as much as you can, but I can't tell you if the beast was corn or grass fed. I like what I like, but I don't like it because of the notes of flavor that are well-understood by the musically-literate ... I like it because it feeds me, fills me, and nourishes me. All of which are excellent reasons for liking music, but none of which will place me in the haloed spotlight streaming out of the clouds of expertdom and thus make me look and sound like I know what the heck I'm talking about.
I thought I'd mentioned it before, but as my search of the archives has not turned it up, perhaps I have not: I once attended a presentation by my old graduate school compatriot, The Professor (this professor, not this professor, whose excellent-metal acquaintance I made much later) that addressed, in very technically impressive terms, The Physics of Music. I was never so good at The Physics as I was at The Math (or even the Chemistry, which makes it all the more ridiculous that I went after The Physics in graduate school), but I may never have been so in love with The Physics as I was that day, when The Professor—a double-major in physics and music—dissected, with deep and adoring abandon, the conjugal relations of the two.
I don't remember the details, but I remember the surprised thrall in the room, and we were (the lot of us) rapt, which was particularly remarkable because we all hated the class—a torturous, required course that was intended to improve our largely limited instructing abilities—so that we might better serve as Graduate Teaching
The Physics, as it pertains to music, you see, is freaking AMAZING!
And when it was over, and The Professor's praises were being sung in off-key but ravingly-enthusiastic tones by He Who Quoteth HisSelf, I remember my own awed and congratulatory response. I also remember knowing that I would never really understand that which I had just heard ... I knew it with absolute and profound certainty, too, because I knew it with my HEART—yet another supporting fact behind the "never really understand" feeling, 'cause if my head HAD been capable of wrapping around it, I would have had at least a little glimmer of "a-HA!" to go with my embossed impression and glittery amazement.
The true sportsman—of game or music—may find it hard to imagine (and sometimes, to accept), but I think that there are those among us meat hunters who are able to nurture our spirits simultaneous to nourishing our bodies. But given the physical reaction that I have to certain songs and specific musical phrases, it's blatantly obvious to me that even though my taste may be deemed hamburger-chic by the musical elite, my soul's savoring it with the same worshipful reverence as if it were tenderloin.
Now if you'll excuse me, all this babbling has made me awfully hungry ...